HomePoliticsExpert questions Mutharika’s decision to assign Chihana cabinet role

Expert questions Mutharika’s decision to assign Chihana cabinet role

Constitutional expert Seodi White questions President Peter Mutharika’s decision to allow Second Vice-President Enoch Chihana to chair Cabinet, raising debate over presidential powers, Vice-President roles and constitutional limits.

Add Nthanda Times on Google

Constitutional Law Expert Seodi White has questioned whether President Peter Mutharika acted within his constitutional powers by allowing Second Vice-President Enoch Chihana to chair a Cabinet meeting while First Vice-President Jane Ansah was reportedly available.

White argues that the decision raises important constitutional questions regarding the powers of the President, the role of Vice-Presidents and the procedures governing Cabinet leadership.

She says the move may have conflicted with Section 92(3) of the Constitution of the Republic of Malawi, which outlines the order of authority for presiding over Cabinet meetings.

The section provides that the President chairs Cabinet meetings, followed by the First Vice-President when the President is unavailable, and then the Second Vice-President when both senior offices are unable to perform the function.

According to White, this creates a constitutional order that must be respected and cannot be changed through administrative decisions.

“The Constitution provides a clear structure for Cabinet leadership and does not allow presidential delegation to bypass the established order,” White argues.

She says while the President has extensive executive powers, those powers must be exercised within the limits established by the Constitution.

The debate follows President Mutharika’s decision to delegate Second Vice-President Enoch Chihana to chair Cabinet proceedings, a move that has sparked discussion over whether constitutional procedures were followed.

White says the issue goes beyond one Cabinet meeting and touches on the broader question of how authority is distributed within Malawi’s Executive branch.

Constitutional Law Expert Seodi White, who has raised questions over President Peter Mutharika’s decision to allow Second Vice-President Enoch Chihana to chair Cabinet, arguing that executive powers must be exercised within constitutional limits

Role of Vice-Presidents

The Constitution of Malawi recognises Vice-Presidents as members of Cabinet whose roles arise directly from the supreme law of the country.

White argues that their participation in Cabinet is not dependent on presidential invitation but is a constitutional responsibility attached to their offices.

She maintains that the position of the First Vice-President carries specific constitutional responsibilities that cannot be reduced through administrative arrangements.

Her analysis references several constitutional provisions, including Sections 79, 80(5), 86(3), 87, 89(6) and 92(1)-(3), which deal with the Executive, presidential powers and Cabinet operations.

She argues that these provisions must be interpreted together to determine the limits of presidential authority.

Presidential Delegation and Constitutional Limits

A key issue in White’s analysis is whether Section 89(6), which gives the President power to delegate certain responsibilities, can be used to allow the Second Vice-President to chair Cabinet when the First Vice-President is available.

While acknowledging that the President has authority to delegate duties, White argues that such powers have limits.

She says delegation cannot be used to override specific constitutional provisions governing Cabinet leadership.

White applies the legal principle lex specialis derogat legi generali, which means that a specific legal provision takes precedence over a general one when the two appear to conflict.

She argues that Section 92(3), which specifically deals with Cabinet leadership, should take priority over the general delegation powers contained in Section 89(6).

According to her interpretation, allowing delegation to bypass the First Vice-President could weaken the constitutional framework and create uncertainty in the exercise of executive authority.

She warns that constitutional arrangements cannot be altered through convenience or political decisions but must follow procedures provided by the Constitution.

Broader Constitutional Debate

The controversy has sparked wider debate about constitutional supremacy, presidential powers and the responsibilities of Vice-Presidents in Malawi’s governance system.

White says the matter highlights the importance of ensuring that all public officials, including the President, exercise authority within constitutional boundaries.

For legal scholars and students, she says the situation provides an opportunity to examine how constitutional principles apply to real political circumstances.

The debate continues to raise questions about executive accountability, separation of powers and respect for constitutional procedures in Malawi’s democracy.

Discussion (0)

You must be signed in with Google or Facebook to join the conversation or reply.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your opinion!

Must Read