Minister of Justice and Constitutional Affairs Charles Mhango has told the Parliamentary Ad-hoc Committee investigating the Chikangawa plane crash that three reports he reviewed on the tragedy were not conclusive enough to bring closure to the circumstances that led to the death of former Vice President Saulos Klaus Chilima and eight others.
Mhango appeared before the committee at Parliament in Lilongwe, where he presented his findings, opinions and recommendations after reviewing the BFU interim report, the Presidential Commission of Inquiry report and the final BFU report.
Speaking after his appearance, Mhango said the reports did not provide sufficient detail on a number of issues surrounding the aircraft’s movement before it crashed on 10 June 2024.
“In my opinion and my analysis of the three reports which I looked at, that is the BFU interim report, the Presidential Commission of Inquiry report and finally the final BFU report, I found all these three reports not conclusive enough, not detailed enough to bring closure to the circumstances which led to the air crash,” Mhango said.

Among the issues Mhango raised was the movement of the aircraft after it left Kamuzu International Airport. He said the aircraft departed at around 9:16 in the morning, and that evidence in the reports showed it later performed what he described as “very strange manoeuvres” before it crashed.
According to Mhango, the reports indicate that around 9:45 or 9:50, the aircraft started going down, going up, circling in some places and changing direction before it eventually impacted the ground at around 10:16.
Mhango said such movements required further scrutiny, especially considering reports that the crew sounded calm when they allegedly communicated with Mzuzu Airport shortly before the crash.
He also questioned why the aircraft reportedly had its landing gear down when it crashed about 34 to 37 kilometres away from Mzuzu Airport.
“Landing gear down in my understanding is that you are preparing to land. Where were they preparing to land at that time?” Mhango asked.
The minister further raised questions around the timing of information at the funeral of the late former Attorney General Ralph Kasambala, where Chilima was expected to represent the then President.
Mhango said the aircraft was expected to land in Mzuzu at around 10:02 before Chilima could proceed by road to the funeral venue. However, he questioned why mourners were reportedly informed around 10 o’clock that the former Vice President would be delayed, before the aircraft had crashed.
“In my opinion, it doesn’t make sense,” Mhango said, arguing that the timing and source of that information should be examined further by the committee.
He said his expectation was that the committee should take the concerns seriously and look into them critically.
Committee chairperson Walter Nyamilandu Manda said the inquiry had not yet reached any conclusion, stressing that the committee was still collecting evidence from witnesses.
Manda said the committee had received information from the Minister of Justice, the Chief Secretary to the President and family members of the late Ralph Kasambala, among others.
“Our investigations are still ongoing, there’s nothing conclusive at this stage,” Manda said.

He said the evidence gathered so far had been insightful and had given the committee “food for thought” on the direction the inquiry should take.
Manda said the committee was currently in the first phase of its work, which focuses on pre-flight planning, authorisation and preparation.
“We are looking at circumstances on how the aircraft was ordered, and the preparations for the flight to take place, and who authorised it, under what circumstances,” he said.
He added that the committee had not yet moved into examining the actual flight itself, saying that would come in later phases of the inquiry.
Chief Secretary to the President Justin Saidi also appeared before the committee and explained procedures followed when the Office of the Vice President requires air transport.
Saidi said he was called to explain operating procedures, including how planes are hired and how communication takes place between the Office of the Vice President and the Office of the President.
He, however, said he could not give details on the specific events of 10 June 2024 because he was not directly involved in the arrangements of that day.
“I cannot talk about issues of 10th June, because I was not part and parcel of that activity,” Saidi said.
Saidi explained that while Vice Presidents have official vehicles, some situations may require faster travel arrangements, including requesting aircraft.
He said such requests can either pass through the Office of the Chief Secretary, which then writes to the President, or through the Vice President’s own secretaries, who can write directly to the President for guidance.
The Ad-hoc Committee is investigating circumstances surrounding the 10 June 2024 crash that killed former Vice President Saulos Chilima and eight others in Chikangawa Forest.


You must be signed in with Google or Facebook to join the conversation or reply.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your opinion!